Open Access Te Herenga Waka-Victoria University of Wellington
Castle_2023_RenegotiatinginGoodFaith.pdf (459.02 kB)

Renegotiating in good faith: How international treaty revisions can deepen cooperation

Download (459.02 kB)
journal contribution
posted on 2023-08-17, 01:57 authored by Matthew CastleMatthew Castle
AbstractInternational agreements are often understood to help governments make credible commitments to future policy by limiting their ability to renege on their promises. Renegotiations of agreements are accordingly viewed as a threat to cooperation, since renegotiations call past commitments into question. But we know little about the frequency or nature of treaty renegotiations. When are international agreements renegotiated, and what effect does renegotiation have on international cooperation? Do most renegotiations indeed aim to backtrack on past commitments? Using the topical context of the trade regime, I collect new data on international treaty revisions, covering 310 preferential trade agreements signed since the year 2000. Around a quarter of these agreements have been amended in some form, and the supermajority of amendments result not in scaled back agreements, but in deeper commitments. Survival analysis shows that ‘like-minded’ countries with a shared language and similar voting patterns at the UN General Assembly are most likely to revise their commitments. In contrast, I do not find evidence to support the view of PTA revisions as ‘backsliding’ on past commitments. The effects of revisions on trade cooperation support the more cooperative view of revisions. An error-correction model shows revisions are associated with a long-run increase in export volumes. Renegotiations are not breakdowns in international relations, but opportunities for governments to renew their commitment to cooperation.


Preferred citation

Castle, M. A. (n.d.). Renegotiating in good faith: How international treaty revisions can deepen cooperation. The Review of International Organizations.

Journal title

The Review of International Organizations


Springer Science and Business Media LLC

Publication status

Published online

Online publication date