Journal of Human Rights and the Environment] Participation as exclusion_ Māori engagement with the Crown Minerals Act 1991 Block Offer process.pdf (203.97 kB)
Participation as exclusion: Māori engagement with the crown minerals act 1991 block offer process
journal contributionposted on 2024-02-01, 20:31 authored by Ema Maria BarghEma Maria Bargh, E Van Wagner
Land and natural resources are at the core of conflicts between Indigenous peoples and Settlers in settler-colonial nations. This article explores the coloniality of natural resource law in the context of the New Zealand Crown Minerals Act 1991 (CMA) Block Offer process; the annual tender process for mineral prospecting and exploration. While there is often strong Mā ori participation, we will argue that Aotearoa New Zealand settler-colonial mining law is structured in such a way that Māori views rarely influence the substantive outcomes of mineral exploration decisions. Through a case study of the 2013 Epithermal Gold Block Offer in the Central North Island, we will explore the factors that might contribute to the mismatch between the level of Māori participation and the influence of Māori views on final decisions in the Block Offer process. We examine how different views are valued by bureaucrats within New Zealand Petroleum and Minerals, a government agency within the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, and explore whether the criteria applied to Mā ori submissions genuinely and appropriately reflect the full range of interests, aspirations and concerns raised by Māori participants. In particular, we consider how mining regulation is structured to exclude Māori law and jurisdiction in order to uphold settler-colonial authority over key natural resources and extractivist economies. Finally, we consider alternatives to the CMA process and explore the potential to ensure substantive outcomes that better reflect the Mā ori views and interests. In doing so we point to the need to shift from colonial extractivist models of natural resources law towards Settler-Indigenous partnerships in relation to environmental planning in settler-colonial states.
Preferred citationBargh, M. & Van Wagner, E. (2019). Participation as exclusion: Māori engagement with the crown minerals act 1991 block offer process. Journal of Human Rights and the Environment, 10(1), 118-139. https://doi.org/10.4337/jhre.2019.01.06
Journal titleJournal of Human Rights and the Environment
PublisherEdward Elgar Publishing
Online publication date2019-03-01