File(s) stored somewhere else

Please note: Linked content is NOT stored on Open Access Victoria University of Wellington | Te Herenga Waka and we can't guarantee its availability, quality, security or accept any liability.

Conduit Companies, Beneficial Ownership, and the Test of Substantive Business Activity in Claims for Relief under Double Tax Treaties

journal contribution
posted on 06.10.2020 by S Jain, J Prebble, K Bunting
If interpreted in a strict legal sense, beneficial ownership rules in tax treaties would have no effect on conduit companies because companies at law own their property and income beneficially. Conversely, a company can never own anything in a substantive sense because economically a company is no more than a congeries of arrangements that represents the people behind it. Faced with these contradictory considerations, people have adopted surrogate tests that they attempt to employ in place of the treaty test of beneficial ownership. An example is that treaty benefits should be limited to companies that are both resident in the states that are parties to the treaty and that carry on substantive business activity. The test is inherently illogical. The origins of the substantive business activity test appear to lie in analogies drawn with straw company and base company cases. Because there is no necessary relationship between ownership and activity, the test of substantive business activity can never provide a coherent surrogate for the test of beneficial ownership. The article finishes with a Coda that summarises suggestions for reform to be made in work that is to follow. © School of Taxation and Business Law (Atax), Australian School of Business The University of New South Wales.

History

Preferred citation

Jain, S., Prebble, J. & Bunting, K. (2013). Conduit Companies, Beneficial Ownership, and the Test of Substantive Business Activity in Claims for Relief under Double Tax Treaties. eJournal of Tax Research (10th Anniversary issue with invited contributions), 11(3), 386-433. http://www.asb.unsw.edu.au/RESEARCH/PUBLICATIONS/EJOURNALOFTAXRESEARCH/Pages/currentissue.aspx

Journal title

eJournal of Tax Research (10th Anniversary issue with invited contributions)

Volume

11

Issue

3

Publication date

01/01/2013

Pagination

386-433

Publication status

Published

Contribution type

Article

eISSN

1448-2398

Exports